Grilling too big a scope runs the agent into the dumb zone
A planning interview about a whole product fills the context window before the plan is done, and answers get worse as it fills.
Reported by @juliandierker · Verified 2026-11-21
- Agent
- Claude Code
- Stack
- Any
Problem
Grilling works so well that it is tempting to grill everything at once. Matt Pocock lists this as the most common mistake: scope is critical.
Setup

/grill-me let's plan the whole v2 of the app/grill-me plan the invite flow for team accounts, nothing elseWhat happened
Without it
Hours of questions, a context window past 120k tokens, answers that contradict earlier ones, and no code.
With it
One feature, one session, then build. If you keep planning without building, you are over-grilling. Don't clear the context just to write the PRD: the interview is the context the PRD needs.
Sources: 9 things people get wrong with /grill-me (AI Hero), Advanced context engineering (HumanLayer).
Reproduce
Run
/contextduring a long grilling session.Note where the answers start contradicting earlier ones.
Split the scope and compare.