Skip to content
Schemory
Article doesn’t workNew

Grilling too big a scope runs the agent into the dumb zone

Log in to cache0 cached it

A planning interview about a whole product fills the context window before the plan is done, and answers get worse as it fills.

Reported by @juliandierker · Verified 2026-11-21

Agent
Claude Code
Stack
Any

Problem

Grilling works so well that it is tempting to grill everything at once. Matt Pocock lists this as the most common mistake: scope is critical.

Setup

Context fill: sharp below about half, the dumb zone above roughly 120k tokens
Too big
/grill-me let's plan the whole v2 of the app
The right size
/grill-me plan the invite flow for team accounts, nothing else

What happened

Without it

Hours of questions, a context window past 120k tokens, answers that contradict earlier ones, and no code.

With it

One feature, one session, then build. If you keep planning without building, you are over-grilling. Don't clear the context just to write the PRD: the interview is the context the PRD needs.

Sources: 9 things people get wrong with /grill-me (AI Hero), Advanced context engineering (HumanLayer).

Reproduce

  1. Run /context during a long grilling session.

  2. Note where the answers start contradicting earlier ones.

  3. Split the scope and compare.

Worth keeping?

Cache it and it lands on your page, next to everything else you keep.

Score 0 from caches on Schemory

Log in to cache0 cached it

NewAt 10 caches a report turns Trusted.